Black FridayUp to −50% on Finmap and financial servicesClaim the discount
Home
/
Blog
/
Injection moulding: who pays for the tool
Case Studies
Manufacturing

Injection moulding: who pays for the tool

Sergiy Shuldik
Sergiy Shuldik
Financial Expert at Finmap

“For seven years I refused to pay for moulds. I used to say: that is tooling for your part, so it belongs to you. And for seven years I could not understand why the orders ran off after a year or eighteen months.”

Solomiia Nakonechna runs a plastics moulding shop in Kalush. Five injection machines, eighteen people, orders for housings, lids and technical parts for local manufacturers. Twelve years in moulding, seven of them as the owner. Full load, a queue of work, her own equipment. And almost no profit.

What a mould is

Every new part demands a mould of its own. It is a steel block machined to one particular geometry, and it fits nothing else.

A new mould at Solomiia's shop costs 180 000 ₴ and stands up to about 400 000 cycles.

Solomiia came into moulding as a technologist and spent twelve years looking at a mould as tooling: service life, accuracy, the cooling system, how many shots before the first repair. The financial side was none of her business then. When she became the owner, the habit of seeing a mould as an instrument stayed, and it turned out to be the most expensive habit of all.

A mould is not a tool but the condition for an order to exist

Without it the part cannot be moulded by anybody anywhere. It is not a machine you can set up differently, and it is not tooling that will suit the next client. A mould exists for exactly one part of exactly one customer.

  • price of a new mould: 180 000 ₴
  • service life: around 400 000 cycles
  • volume of one order: 60 000 parts a year
  • the client usually promises three years, which is 180 000 parts

So over the promised three years the mould will produce exactly a third of its service life. Physically it will outlive any order — the only question is who paid for it.

What the service life says

Four hundred thousand cycles is a figure worth holding on to.

An order for 60 000 parts a year takes six and a half years to use that life up. The promised three years are 180 000 cycles, less than half. So a mould almost always outlives the order it was made for.

  • service life of a mould: around 400 000 cycles
  • volume of an order: 60 000 parts a year
  • the promised three years take 180 000 cycles, less than half
  • the full service life would be used up in 6.5 years

Steel does not wear out, agreements do

This is the strangest thing in the whole story. The asset stays physically fit for years and dies economically along with the client — not because it broke, but because nobody needs the part any more. A mould for the lid of one particular housing has no alternative value at all.

“I have four moulds sitting in my store from clients who no longer exist. All of them work. All of them cost a hundred and eighty thousand. I cannot sell them and I cannot convert them — I can only look at them.”

What one part brings

A part goes to the client at 14.20 ₴. Material and processing take 9.80 ₴.

The contribution is 4.40 ₴.

Of those four forty, one hryvnia goes on the mould. It looks like a cost and cannot look like anything else as long as you are looking at a single part.

A mould's depreciation eats almost a quarter of the contribution

Spread 180 000 ₴ over the promised 180 000 parts and you get exactly 1.00 ₴ a part. That is 22.73% of the contribution — almost a quarter of what the part brings in.

It was that figure which made the choice obvious in Solomiia's head: paying for a mould meant handing over a quarter of the earnings.

Twenty-two kopiykas out of a hryvnia. That is what the shop keeps from the price of a part before fixed costs and tooling even begin. The rest goes on material, because polypropylene and ABS are bought at world prices, and there is nobody here to haggle with.

The shop's year

LineAmount, ₴Comment
Revenue18 744 0001 320 000 parts × 14.20 ₴
Material and processing12 936 000× 9.80 ₴
Contribution5 808 000× 4.40 ₴
Fixed costs4 560 000shop, 18 people, rent
Depreciation of moulds540 0009 orders on the shop's own
Net profit708 0003.8% of revenue

Three point eight percent. For moulding to order that is low, and Solomiia knew it was low.

And there is 1 620 000 ₴ lying in the moulds at the same time — 2.29 times more than the whole year's profit.

All six lines of the report are correct. Solomiia drew them up herself, from delivery notes and the bank, and has never once found an error in them. The report simply does not carry the line that would say how long each client stays a client.

Two schemes, one shop

A mould can be paid for by the client or by the shop. Technologically there is no difference whatsoever; legally the difference is enormous.

When the client pays, the mould is his. When the shop pays, it is the shop's.

Legally this is a simple thing everybody knows and nobody counts. A mould is movable property, and the contract always says whose it is. The parties sign that clause in thirty seconds and go back to arguing about the price of a part, where they fight over kopiykas.

Whoever owns the mould decides where the part is moulded

A client with his own mould can take it away whenever he likes and carry it off to a competitor who only has to quote a few percent less. The move costs him the haulage and a week of setting up.

A client with the shop's mould can do nothing. To leave, he has to order a new mould for 180 000 ₴ and wait two months for it.

Two months is the real cost of moving for a client with his own mould. Haul it, set it up, mould a trial batch, get it approved. For a client with the shop's mould it is no longer two months, it is 180 000 ₴ and two months.

How long an order lasts

Solomiia pulled up seven years of history and counted the two schemes separately.

An order on a client's mould lasts 1.6 years on average. On the shop's own mould, 3.4.

The figures are not perfect: a sample over seven years, orders in the dozens rather than the hundreds, and every one of them with its own reason for leaving. But the gap between 1.6 and 3.4 is too wide to be a coincidence, and it holds in both directions — among the big clients as much as among the small ones.

A client with the shop's mould stays 2.12 times longer.

“I got that figure and spent half a day refusing to accept it. What it came to was that for seven years I had saved a hundred and eighty thousand and paid for it with a client who leaves twice as fast.”

There is one more reason the shop can offer this at all. The mould is made not by Solomiia but by a toolroom, and it takes two months to make whoever is paying for it. So the scheme with the shop's mould does not add the client a single day of waiting, and that removes the one argument he could raise against it.

The arithmetic over the whole term

Over the whole order termThe client's mouldThe shop's mould
Contribution per part, ₴4.403.40
Contribution a year, ₴264 000204 000
Order term, years1.63.4
Contribution over the whole term, ₴422 400693 600
Shop's capital at the start, ₴0180 000

Four hundred and twenty-two against six hundred and ninety-three. A difference of 1.64 times, and it favours the scheme that brings in less per part.

The mould turned out to be a lock, not a cost.

The contribution of a part on the shop's mould is 3.40 ₴, which is 77.27% of the 4.40 ₴ a client's mould gives. The shop knowingly hands over almost a quarter of the earnings on a part. And it gets more than twice the term in exchange.

Why the costing does not show it

A part costing counts hryvnias per unit. In it 3.40 ₴ is always worse than 4.40 ₴, and that is true.

  • a costing measures the part, not the order
  • the lifetime of an order is not a financial indicator at all
  • the mould sits in the books as a fixed asset, separately from the part
  • a client who leaves produces no cost line at all

To see the 1.64 times, the contribution has to be multiplied by the term. No costing does that, because the term is not part of it.

All four lines are there in the accounts. Not one of them is missing, and not one will have to be entered from scratch. They have simply never been multiplied by one another.

And the opposite is worth saying too. In the scheme with the client's mould the shop carries a risk as well, just a different one: it puts two months into setting the process up, picking the regimes and running the first trial batches, and all that knowledge walks out with the mould to the competitor. That cost appears in no table, because it sits in people and not in money.

A risk that is just as real

The scheme with the shop's mould has a price, and it has to be named.

If an order dies at 1.6 years, the shop has produced 96 000 parts instead of 180 000. Depreciated, 96 000 ₴; left unamortised, 84 000 ₴.

Eighty-four thousand. On one mould that is unpleasant; on nine of them it is already a sum to keep in mind with every new order.

An unamortised mould is steel nobody will buy

It cannot be converted for another part and it cannot be sold to anyone except that same customer. A steel block is worth scrap value, a few thousand against eighty-four.

Across the nine moulds of the shop that is 756 000 ₴ — 1.07 times more than the shop's annual profit.

“That was my argument for all seven years. I used to say: and what if he leaves? And I was right, he really can leave. I just never counted that with his own mould he leaves for certain.”

Twenty kilometres to the competitor. It is that distance which makes the question of the mould a financial one rather than a legal one: it decides how easily an order can move.

What was tried before

The first attempts were about price, not about moulds.

Solomiia put the price of a part up, negotiated advances, brought in a minimum batch for a start-up. All of it helped a little and changed nothing in the main thing: a client with his own mould stayed free to leave whenever he liked.

So the question was not how much to earn on a part but whether that part would still be there next year.

Why the shop has a choice at all

In Kalush moulding is no exotic trade. Chemical production is next door, the raw material is close, and there are several shops with injection machines here.

That is exactly why the question of the mould is so sharp. When the competitor is twenty kilometres away, moving an order is not a hypothesis but an ordinary event the client thinks over every year when the price is reviewed.

In a town with one shop a mould decides nothing: the client is going nowhere. In Kalush it decides everything, and that changes the whole arithmetic of choosing a scheme.

A minimum volume in the contract

The answer turned out to lie halfway between the two schemes.

The shop pays for the mould itself, but the client signs up to a minimum volume: 40 000 parts a year. If he does not take them, he pays the depreciation on what he did not take, at 1.00 ₴ a part.

The minimum does not cover the mould, it caps the loss

Forty thousand parts give 40 000 ₴ of depreciation a year. To cover 180 000 ₴ out of the minimum alone would take 4.5 years, more than the promised three. So the minimum does not guarantee payback; it only stops an order from dying for free at the client's end.

“I was afraid of that conversation for a month. I thought they would say: you want us to sign obligations on top of everything else? And the very first client answered: at last, because the shop before you made our mould and then shut down, and it took us two months to get it out of the plant.”

Who agreed

The shop takes on seven new orders a year. Solomiia offered the new scheme to all seven.

Five agreed. Two refused — both of them big, both with technologists of their own, both saying the mould had to be theirs.

How to run the seven new ordersContribution over the term, ₴
All on the client's mould2 956 800
Force everybody, two walk away entirely3 468 000
Five on the minimum, two on their own4 312 800

It is worth saying why those particular two refused. Both are large, both have technologists of their own and several moulding suppliers. For them owning the mould is not a financial decision but a procurement rule that nobody in their company is allowed to change.

Two figures instead of one. That is what separates the shop's new offer from the old one: the client sees the price of a part and the length of the commitment side by side, and chooses for himself which matters more.

Why flexibility wins

The mixed approach gives 4 312 800 ₴ — 1.46 times more than the old one and 1.24 times more than the hard one.

Two schemes together beat either one alone

The reason is simple. The hard scheme loses two clients outright, and the old one loses all seven after eighteen months. The mixed one holds five of them for a long time and two for a short time, and the total comes out larger than either extreme.

Solomiia did not try to talk those two round. She simply worked out that they are worth their 422 400 ₴ each and took them on the old terms without any resentment.

Plain addition does the rest. Had she turned the two of them away, she would have lost 844 800 ₴ of contribution over the term, and no victory on principle would have covered that.

What Solomiia changed

“I now ask a client not „whose mould is it going to be“ but „how many parts are you signing up for“. One question instead of an argument, and the answer shows straight away what this client is worth.”

  • the offer to a client now contains two schemes with different prices per part
  • every mould has a card of its own: volume, term, how many parts it has already paid itself back over
  • a decision on a new order is worked out on the contribution over the term, not on the contribution per part
  • the unamortised balance is visible every month, not once a year

The third point turned out to be the main one. Until then Solomiia compared 4.40 ₴ and 3.40 ₴ — two figures between which the choice is obvious and wrong.

Solomiia has not written off the four moulds in the corner of the store. She keeps them as a reminder: every one of them works, every one cost a hundred and eighty thousand, and not one is needed by anybody any more. It is the most expensive teaching aid in the shop.

The money does not vanish — you simply do not see it

“For twelve years I counted the hryvnias in a part. And the dearest thing in my shop is not the material and not the machines, it is how long a client stays mine. And that time is bought with a steel block for a hundred and eighty thousand.”

Nothing in Solomiia's shop changed: not the equipment, not the price of a part, not the cost of the material. Still five machines, twenty-two orders, the same 4.40 ₴ of contribution per part. The only thing that changed is that the decision about a mould is now taken with two figures instead of one.

How to see this across your own orders

Everything above rests on one cut the part costing does not make: a tool is not a cost line, it is the length of time a client stays with you. While tooling is counted together with material, the shop's own mould looks like the worse option, because a part earns 3.40 ₴ instead of 4.40 ₴, and it is not visible that an order on it lives 3.4 years instead of 1.6. When tool cost, volume and order term are held in one place on their own, 756 000 ₴ of undepreciated exposure stops being a surprise — which is exactly why owners of small and medium businesses use Finmap: to see the financial picture instead of piecing it together.

Read also

Table of Contents
Check the Status of Your Business's Financial System
Order Financial Diagnostics
Sergiy Shuldik
Sergiy Shuldik
Financial Expert at Finmap
  • Consultations on commercial activities and management. Financial planning and strategy.
  • CFO, NDA (2023–2025).
  • Financial and economic security analyst at Letishops LLC (2019–2021).
  • Chief accountant, Public Sector / Ministry of Defense of Ukraine (2014–2019).

Recommended for Entrepreneurs

Frequently asked questions about custom moulding finances

Who should pay for the mould?

Count not the price of the tool but the lifetime of the order. The client's mould gives the shop 4.40 ₴ of contribution per part, but the order lasts 1.6 years; the shop's own gives 3.40 ₴, and the order holds for 3.4 years. Over the whole term that is 422 400 ₴ against 693 600 ₴, which is 1.64 times more.

Divide the cost of the tool by the volume it was made for. Here 180 000 ₴ over 180 000 parts gives exactly 1.00 ₴ a part, which is 22.73% of the contribution. It matters that you take the promised volume and not the service life: 400 000 cycles would only be used up in 6.5 years.

Because it costs him almost nothing. Moving the tool to a competitor means the haulage and a week of setting up. For a client on the shop's mould the same move costs 180 000 ₴ for a new tool and two months of waiting.

The unamortised balance, if the order dies early. At death in the 1.6th year the shop has made 96 000 parts and depreciated 96 000 ₴, while 84 000 ₴ stay in steel that can be neither converted nor sold. Across nine moulds that is 756 000 ₴, more than the shop's annual profit.

With a minimum volume in the contract. The client signs up to 40 000 parts a year and pays the depreciation at 1.00 ₴ on whatever he does not take. It does not cover the tool — covering 180 000 ₴ out of the minimum alone would take 4.5 years — but it stops the order dying for free at the client's end.

Take them on the old terms rather than turn them down. Out of seven new orders five agreed and two refused, both of them large, both with procurement rules of their own. The mixed approach gives 4 312 800 ₴ against 3 468 000 ₴ for the hard scheme, because the two refusers are still worth 422 400 ₴ each.

Because it measures the part and not the order. In a costing 3.40 ₴ is always worse than 4.40 ₴, and that is true. The lifetime of the order simply does not enter into it, and it is the lifetime that decides how many parts there will ever be.

The volume it was made for, the actual output, how many parts it has already paid itself back over, and the unamortised balance. That last figure is worth seeing every month rather than once a year: it shows how much money in your shop has nowhere to go if the client leaves.

Any questions left?
We are ready to answer them.
WhatsApp
Telegram
Finmap
Finmap support

Money Doesn't Disappear. You Just Don't See It.

Get a personal financial diagnosis or a Finmap demo — and see your business from a new perspective.

Ask Your Question to a Finmap Expert