“For two years I fought for the fat content of our raw milk. I paid the farms extra, drove around them, bragged that we had the fattest milk in the district. Then I worked out that this fat content had cost me one and a half annual profits.”
Maksym Shcherbyna runs a dairy plant in Kaniv. Fifteen years in dairy processing, seven of them as the owner. Fourteen thousand tonnes of milk a year: drinking milk, butter, skim milk and buttermilk. Thirty-eight people.
The year closes with 7 188 000 ₴ of profit on revenue of 275 988 000 ₴. A little over two and a half percent. In dairy processing that is the norm, and that is exactly why a mistake the size of one and a half profits can go unnoticed here for years.
Maksym looked for it in the cost of production, in the logistics, in the losses on the line. It was sitting in the purchasing formula — the same one every plant in the trade signs and nobody ever questions.
What a dairy plant pays for
Not for milk. For the fat in the milk.
That is the defining feature of the trade, and it is no accident: fat is the dearest component of milk and the easiest one to measure. The lab gives an answer in minutes and there is nothing to argue about.
The purchasing formula works like this: there is a base fat content, there is a price for one percent of fat in a tonne, and the supplier gets paid for as many points as he brought in. At Maksym's plant that is 4 000 ₴ a point.
- a tonne of milk at 3.6% fat costs 14 400 ₴
- the same tonne at 3.4% would cost 13 600 ₴
- every 0.2 of a point is 800 ₴ on a tonne
- across 14 000 tonnes, every 0.2 of a point is 11 200 000 ₴ a year
Remember that last line. The whole article rests on it.
The formula is fair and clear to both sides. A farm that feeds its herd better gets paid more, and that is right. The question is not about the formula but about what the plant does with the fat it has already paid for.
How much fat comes into the plant
Fourteen thousand tonnes of milk at 3.6% fat is 504 tonnes of fat.
Fat does not disappear and does not appear from nowhere. All of it has to end up in some product, and each product takes exactly as much as its recipe prescribes.
Where it goes
Drinking milk is standardised to 2.5%. Ten thousand tonnes of it take 250 tonnes of fat — almost half of what comes in.
Butter is 80% fat. The line turns out 300 tonnes of butter a year, and that is another 240 tonnes of fat.
Three hundred tonnes is the limit of the equipment, not of the market. The churn will not beat more than that, and raising the figure takes a new line with everything that comes attached to it.
Fourteen tonnes with nowhere to go
Add it up: 250 plus 240 is 490 tonnes.
And 504 came in. Fourteen tonnes of fat a year have nowhere to go.
That is less than three percent of all the fat that comes in. Which is exactly why the question never came up: a trifle, a rounding error, a leftover.
It is handed over as cream to the plant next door at 22 000 ₴ per tonne of fat. That is 308 000 ₴ a year — a figure so small it is barely visible in the report.
The neighbouring plant takes it gladly: it has a bigger butter line and a permanent shortage of fat. For them that cream is a good buy, which is precisely why the price is what it is.
“The cream went in a line of its own right at the bottom. I looked at it once a quarter and thought: well, there it is.”
Where every tonne ends up
It helps to picture a dairy plant as a fork in the road.
| Where the fat goes | Tonnes of fat | What comes of it |
|---|---|---|
| Drinking milk | 250 | 10 000 t at 20 200 ₴ |
| Butter | 240 | 300 t at 232 000 ₴ |
| Cream sold off | 14 | 308 000 ₴ |
| Total from fat-bearing products | 504 | 271 908 000 ₴ |
Why there are exactly three branches
The first two are set by the equipment and the recipe: how much drinking milk the filling line puts out and how much butter the churn beats. The third branch is not a decision but a remainder. Everything that did not fit into the first two goes there.
The sum on the bottom line is the revenue from the fat-bearing products alone. Skim milk and buttermilk are not included: they bring another 4 080 000 ₴, but there is almost no fat in them, so they do not belong to this arithmetic.
What fat is really worth
Now the main comparison of the article, and it has to be made carefully.
You cannot say “a tonne of fat costs us 400 000 ₴”. Those 14 400 ₴ a tonne of milk are not paid for the fat alone: a tonne also holds 964 kilos of water, protein and lactose, and they become product too.
How to compare it properly
What has to be compared is marginal fat — that same single point of fat you can either add or not add.
| One point of fat in a tonne | Hryvnias |
|---|---|
| The plant pays for it | 4 000 ₴ |
| In butter it returns | 2 900 ₴ |
| In cream it returns | 220 ₴ |
Marginal fat costs more than it returns even in its best possible destination.
Why this does not mean butter loses money
An important qualification, without which the conclusion comes out wrong.
Butter does not lose money. It simply cannot pay back fat bought at the marginal price. Fat that has already come into the plant with the main flow of milk is put to good use by butter: 2 900 ₴ a point against 220 ₴ in cream is 13.18 times more.
The question is not whether to make butter. The question is whether it is worth paying extra for fat that will then have to go into butter.
The difference between those two questions is what separates a production decision from a purchasing decision. The first is about what to do with what you have. The second is about how much to take.
What was tried before
Maksym decided to raise the fat content of the raw milk from 3.6% to 3.8%.
The logic was flawless: fatter milk means a better product, more butter, less water in the tonnes. He agreed a premium with the farms, changed the herd ration at the two biggest ones, and spent two years on the work.
The fat content went up. Everything else stayed the same.
The whole loss is hidden in those four words. Fat content was the only thing that changed, while every other decision the plant had made stayed where it was: the same drinking milk recipe, the same limit on the butter line, the same buyer for the cream.
What came of it
Fat coming in went to 532 tonnes instead of 504.
Twenty-eight tonnes — not a bad addition, you would think. In butter they would have made 35 tonnes of finished product, and that is exactly how Maksym pictured the result.
Drinking milk did not change: it was standardised to 2.5% before and it still is. The butter line pulled 300 tonnes before and still does. The same 490 tonnes are all the plant knows how to place.
Where the extra twenty-eight tonnes went
Into cream. Surplus fat went to 42 tonnes instead of 14, and the extra revenue came to 616 000 ₴.
And the premium for fat content came to 11 200 000 ₴.
The effect: minus 10 584 000 ₴ a year. That is 1.47 times the plant's annual profit: a minus bigger than the whole profit.
“When I saw that figure, the first thing I did was check the purchasing formula. I thought I had got the multiplier wrong. I had not.”
Why the mistake was invisible
Because not one part of it looked like a mistake.
The premium for fat sat in purchasing and looked like ordinary raw material inflation — milk was getting dearer anyway. The cream sat at the bottom of the report and even grew a little.
Where the substitution happens
The plant measured fat at intake and took pride in it. But fat at intake is a property of the raw material, not of the product. The product is standardised, and its fat content is set by the recipe rather than by what was delivered.
All fat above the recipe is not an advantage but a leftover that has to be put somewhere.
Fat at intake makes sense in exactly three cases:
- when you sell fat as a separate product and demand for it is unlimited
- when your products are richer in fat than the average raw material
- when the purchasing formula pays for the tonne rather than for the fat
Not one of the three applied at Maksym's plant.
The move that works
“People told me: you have the fattest milk in the district. I used to hear that as praise. Now I hear it as a diagnosis.”
Maksym took the purchasing fat content back to 3.6% — the experiment had cost far too much to keep running. And then he changed what he had not touched in years: the recipe of the drinking milk.
Three percent instead of 2.5%. The price of a tonne rises from 20 200 ₴ to 21 800 ₴ along with it, because fatter drinking milk really is worth more on the shelf.
- the fat going into drinking milk is 300 tonnes instead of 250
- 204 tonnes of fat are left for butter, which is 255 tonnes of butter instead of 300
- there is no surplus fat at all
- cream disappears as a line
Butter output fell by 45 tonnes.
What it gave
The arithmetic is short.
| Item | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Drinking milk | 202 000 000 ₴ | 218 000 000 ₴ |
| Butter | 69 600 000 ₴ | 59 160 000 ₴ |
| Cream | 308 000 ₴ | — |
| Effect | — | 5 252 000 ₴ |
Five million two hundred and fifty-two thousand is 73.1% of annual profit.
The purchasing formula itself did not change by a single hryvnia. The same price per point of fat, the same suppliers, the same requirements on the raw milk.
One line in the process sheet changed, and that is all. The standardiser was set to a different figure, the label was redrawn and the chains were told about the new fat content. The whole job took a month and a half, and most of it went on getting the packaging approved.
Two decisions about fat
Put them side by side and the whole article fits into two lines.
Raising the fat content of what you buy: minus 10 584 000 ₴. Raising the fat content of what you sell: plus 5 252 000 ₴.
The fat you pay for and the fat you sell are two different fats, and the one to manage is the second.
“For two years I carried fat content to the plant. I should have been carrying it to the shop.”
“The technologist resisted for a month. He said we were cutting butter. We were not cutting butter — we stopped driving fat into it that had no business being there.”
Why there is less butter and more money
This is the place that unsettles everyone Maksym has told about it.
Forty-five tonnes of butter is 10 440 000 ₴ of revenue given up. But each of those tonnes took 800 kilos of fat with it, and the same fat gives more in drinking milk.
When it will be the other way round
If butter rises in price relative to drinking milk, the arithmetic turns over. What has to be compared is not the products against each other but how many hryvnias one and the same point of fat gives in each of them.
This comparison is worth redoing every time the price list moves, even on a single item.
And one more thing, so as not to make the opposite mistake. The new recipe gives 3 200 ₴ per point of fat in a tonne of drinking milk — more than butter does, but less than the 4 000 ₴ it costs to buy. Buying fat in has not become worthwhile; what has become more worthwhile is where the fat that already arrives ends up.
In practice one table with three columns is enough: the product, how much fat it takes per tonne, how many hryvnias that fat gives. Recalculating it is fifteen minutes once a quarter.
Would a bigger butter line not be simpler
This is the first thing everybody suggests when you show them the fat balance.
If the recipe had been left alone, a bigger churn really would get rid of the cream: 504 tonnes of fat would fit into drinking milk and butter with nothing left over. But every point of fat in butter returns 2 900 ₴ against 4 000 ₴ in purchasing, so a new line would use the fat more efficiently rather than more profitably.
When the line really is needed
When the price of butter grows faster than the price of drinking milk. While one point of fat is cheaper in butter than the same point in drinking milk, the money is in the recipe, not in the equipment.
“The first slide at our planning meeting is now the fat balance. Not volumes, not raw milk fat content. How much came in and where it went.”
What to watch every month
Three figures are enough, and raw milk fat content is not among them.
- the fat balance: how much came in, how much went into each product, how much was left over
- hryvnias per point of fat in each product, as a separate line for every line of production
- the volume of cream handed off, in tonnes of fat rather than in hryvnias
If the third line is above zero, you are buying fat you have found no place for. If it is growing, you are buying more and more of it.
None of the three asks for a new accounting system. Intake already records fat content, the process sheets already set the recipes, the invoices already show prices. All that is missing is pulling them into one balance once a month.
The money does not vanish — you simply do not see it
Dairy processing looks like a business about milk. It is really about fat: how much of it you bought and how much of it you managed to sell at the full price.
Maksym did not have a raw material quality problem. He had a purchasing formula that pays for fat and a recipe that does not take it.
Two years of fighting for fat content cost 10 584 000 ₴. One recipe change brought 5 252 000 ₴. Both figures are true, and between them lies the whole difference between what you buy and what you sell.
How to see this at your own plant
All the arithmetic above rests on one row the production report does not have: the fat balance — how much came in, how much went into each product and how much was left over. While the plant measures fat at intake, neither the 10 584 000 ₴ that raising it by 0.2 points cost nor the 5 252 000 ₴ that one recipe change brought is visible. When the same data is collected automatically, the hryvnia per point of fat is visible for every line — which is exactly why owners of small and medium businesses use Finmap: to see the financial picture rather than reconstruct it from memory.
Read also
- Dairy farm: a cow is milked 305 days and eats 365
- Artisan Cheese Dairy: Batch Cost, Aging and Cash Frozen in the Cellar
Topic foundation: Management Accounting Explained: What It Is and Why Owners Need It
Questions that come up right away
Because there is nowhere to put the surplus fat. Drinking milk is standardised to the same 2.5%, the butter line pulls the same 300 tonnes, so the 28 extra tonnes of fat went into cream at 22 000 ₴ per tonne of fat. The premium came to 11 200 000 ₴ and 616 000 ₴ came back — minus 10 584 000 ₴.
It is 1.47 times the annual profit, which is 7 188 000 ₴ on revenue of 275 988 000 ₴. The minus exceeds the profit, though not by double. And the main thing is that every part of it looked perfectly normal on its own.
What has to be counted is marginal fat, meaning one point of fat in a tonne. The plant pays 4 000 ₴ for it, butter returns 2 900 ₴, cream 220 ₴. You cannot say “a tonne of fat costs 400 000 ₴”: those 14 400 ₴ are paid for the volume and the protein as well.
No. Butter simply cannot pay back fat bought at the marginal price. Fat that has already come into the plant with the main flow is put to good use by butter: 2 900 ₴ a point against 220 ₴ in cream is 13.18 times more.
In come 504 tonnes: 14 000 tonnes of milk at 3.6% fat. Drinking milk takes 250 tonnes, butter 240, which is 490 together. Fourteen tonnes a year are left over and go as cream to the plant next door for 308 000 ₴.
Drinking milk fat content went from 2.5% to 3.0% and the price of a tonne rose from 20 200 ₴ to 21 800 ₴. Revenue from drinking milk climbed to 218 000 000 ₴, revenue from butter fell to 59 160 000 ₴, and cream disappeared. The net effect is 5 252 000 ₴, or 73.1% of annual profit.
Because every tonne of butter takes 800 kilos of fat, and the same fat gives more in drinking milk. Butter output was 255 tonnes instead of 300, which is 45 tonnes less, but no surplus fat was left at all. If butter rises in price relative to drinking milk, the arithmetic turns over.
A bigger line would get rid of the cream, but every point of fat in butter returns 2 900 ₴ against 4 000 ₴ in purchasing. A new line would use the fat more efficiently rather than more profitably. While a point of fat is cheaper in butter than the same point in drinking milk, the money is in the recipe, not in the equipment.
