Black FridayUp to −50% on Finmap and financial servicesClaim the discount
Home
/
Blog
/
Intensive orchard: the planting depreciation nobody books
Case Studies
Manufacturing

Intensive orchard: the planting depreciation nobody books

Olena Smolikova
Olena Smolikova
Financial expert at Finmap

“People told me: you have a twenty-six per cent margin, you are the best in the district. And I could not buy a new grading line and did not understand why. It turned out that two thirds of that profit is an orchard wearing out under my feet.”

Oksana Hrytsenko runs an intensive apple orchard in Nemyriv. Thirteen years in fruit growing, nine of them as the owner. Twenty-four hectares on trellis with drip irrigation, her own cold store and a grading line. Eleven people on the staff, pickers hired for the season.

The orchard brings in 8 568 000 ₴ of revenue and 2 254 000 ₴ of profit. Both figures are correct. The second one simply describes something other than what Oksana thought.

What the report shows

A year in an orchard is counted simply.

ItemFor the year
Revenue8 568 000 ₴
Orchard care1 932 000 ₴
Picking1 285 200 ₴
Grading and storage856 800 ₴
Fixed costs2 240 000 ₴
Profit2 254 000 ₴ (26.3%)

Twenty-six per cent for fruit growing really is good. That is the very figure Oksana showed the bank, and the bank accepted it.

The trouble started when something had to be bought. A new grading line, another cold store module, a replacement for the old tractor — there was never money for any of it, although the report showed more than two million of profit year after year.

The orchard by age

An intensive orchard is never uniform. It is planted in blocks, and blocks of different ages live completely different lives.

Age of blockAreaPer hectare
Young, 1-3 years6 hanothing
Coming into bearing, 4-5 years6 ha18 t
Mature, 6 years and older12 ha42 t

The mature blocks give 504 tonnes, those coming into bearing 108. Together that is 612 tonnes at 14 000 ₴ a tonne.

A block coming into bearing gives less than half of what a mature one gives, although the care on it is already the full programme. It is an in-between state in which a hectare already earns but does not yet pay for itself.

The six young hectares give nothing. Half the orchard has not yet reached a full crop, and that is not a breakdown, it is the norm of intensive fruit growing.

An orchard where every block is the same age looks convenient exactly once — in its first twenty years. Then the whole of it ages at once, and the owner faces having to replant everything and spend three years with no revenue. That is why blocks are deliberately planted in waves.

What is in no line at all

Establishing a hectare costs 1 240 000 ₴.

Young trees, trellis, the drip system, the planting itself. Oksana paid that money and wrote it off as a cost of the year she planted in. Almost every fruit grower does the same, and in bookkeeping terms there is nothing to object to.

“I wrote the planting off in the year I planted it and never thought about it again. The orchard is standing there. It has not gone anywhere.”

“I used to think an orchard was land. Land does not wear out. It turned out that an orchard is equipment which merely looks like land.”

The trouble is that a planting does not stand forever. The productive life of an intensive orchard is twenty years. Then the block is grubbed out and planted anew.

What that is in money

Divide 1 240 000 ₴ by twenty years — 62 000 ₴ per hectare every year.

Across all twenty-four hectares that is 1 488 000 ₴ a year.

Why this is not an abstraction

Twenty years only seems a long time while the orchard is young.

Because in twenty years that block will have to be replanted, and the money for the replanting has to come from somewhere. If it is not set aside, it comes out of a loan or it does not come at all, and the orchard simply loses yield little by little.

When Oksana bought the holding, the oldest blocks were ten years old. Now they are nineteen, which means the term is running into its last year. It arrives quietly: there will never be a day when the orchard suddenly stops bearing.

Planting depreciation is not a bookkeeping formality. It is a payment schedule the orchard hands the owner, only with no invoice and no due date.

Two profits

Take the depreciation away and the picture changes.

2 254 000 ₴ minus 1 488 000 ₴ equals 766 000 ₴.

Two thirds of the visible profit is an orchard wearing out.

What the percentage is taken from

The depreciation is 66.0% of the profit. The same sum against revenue is 17.4%.

Both figures are true and both describe one thing. But when people say “depreciation eats two thirds”, they mean the profit and not the revenue, and that base has to be named out loud.

The real margin of the orchard is 8.94% of revenue against the visible 26.3%.

A young hectare

Now the most interesting part.

A young block gives no crop, but it does not stop costing.

What the care consists of

A young tree needs no less attention than a grown one, and in places more:

  • formative pruning, on which the crop of the next fifteen years depends
  • spraying on the full programme, because diseases do not ask about age
  • watering and feeding through the drip system
  • tying in to the trellis and replacing the trees that died
  • care of a young hectare — 64 000 ₴ a year
  • depreciation of the same hectare — 62 000 ₴ a year
  • together — 126 000 ₴ every year
  • and that for three years until the first crop

Six young hectares cost 756 000 ₴ a year.

And now put that sum next to the real profit. 766 000 ₴ against 756 000 ₴.

The difference between them is 10 000 ₴.

“When I saw those two figures side by side, I first thought I had made a mistake in the arithmetic. Then I did it over three times.”

Six hectares that still give nothing take 756 000 ₴ a year including depreciation — almost exactly what is left to the owner. Not more than that — a little less. But so close that the owner's whole freedom consists of those ten thousand.

What goes in before the first hryvnia

Let us count one hectare from planting.

Establishment 1 240 000 ₴. Plus three years of care at 64 000 ₴, that is 192 000 ₴. Together 1 432 000 ₴ in live money before the block gives back its first hryvnia.

Why exactly three years

An intensive orchard on dwarf rootstocks starts bearing in its third or fourth year, and the first crops are small. A block gives a full crop from its sixth year. Before that it either does not bear or bears so little that it does not even cover the picking.

When a hectare gives the money back

A mature hectare gives 42 tonnes, which is 588 000 ₴ of revenue.

The costs on it: 86 000 ₴ of care, 88 200 ₴ of picking, 58 800 ₴ of grading and storage, 62 000 ₴ of depreciation. Together 295 000 ₴.

The contribution is 293 000 ₴ per hectare.

Note that the depreciation is already inside here. That is exactly how a hectare's contribution has to be counted: otherwise the contribution of a mature hectare would seem 355 000 ₴ instead of 293 000 ₴, and any comparison with replanting loses its meaning.

Divide 1 432 000 ₴ by 293 000 ₴ and you get 4.89 years of full bearing. And full bearing only starts in the sixth year, so about ten years pass between the young tree and the money coming back.

What was tried before

The first attempts were about price and about yield.

Oksana negotiated a better price with the chains, changed the variety mix, put in extra drip lines. All of it worked, and every such step added a few per cent.

Not one of them touched what was standing in the orchard in the form of six hectares with no crop.

There was a fourth attempt as well: cut back the care of the young blocks. The logic is simple — they do not bear anyway, so why the full spraying programme. The agronomist refused flatly, and he was right: the few tens of thousands saved turn into a lost crown shape, and that is tonnes gone for twenty years ahead.

“For three years I tried to earn more from a tonne. What I should have looked at was how many of my hectares give tonnes at all.”

Why she wanted to plant more

An orchard owner's logic is simple: more hectares, more apples.

Oksana was planning to add six hectares. The land was there, the water was there, the demand was there. It all looked obvious.

Where the substitution happens

Every new hectare is 1 240 000 ₴ at once and 64 000 ₴ of care every year for three years with not a kopeck of revenue. Six hectares are 7 440 000 ₴ in live money.

And that is only the establishment. Three years of care on each of the six hectares — another 1 152 000 ₴ in live money.

Against the real profit of 766 000 ₴ the establishment alone is 9.71 years. Almost ten years of the orchard working to pay for the planting itself, which will start giving back only in its fourth year.

Two options that look different

There is another way: do not add area, replant the oldest blocks.

The oldest six hectares are nearing the end of their term. When it runs out, a hectare gives not 42 tonnes but 26. The trellis and the drip on them are standing and will serve a while yet, so replanting costs 740 000 ₴ a hectare instead of 1 240 000 ₴.

IndicatorReplantingNew ground
Investment per hectare740 000 ₴1 240 000 ₴
Gain in contribution168 000 ₴293 000 ₴
Payback4.4 years4.23 years
Money for 6 ha4 440 000 ₴7 440 000 ₴

Twenty-six tonnes instead of forty-two is not a disease and not a mistake in the care. It is the age the block will reach in a year: the tree has used up its resource, the crown has thickened, part of the branches no longer bear, and the fruit size is falling.

A hectare at the end of its term gives 364 000 ₴ of revenue against costs of 239 000 ₴, so a contribution of 125 000 ₴. Replanting lifts it to 293 000 ₴, and that is a gain of 168 000 ₴. The comparison is made exactly at that moment: replanting a block that still gives a full crop would give no gain at all.

The payback is almost the same

And here is what came out unexpected.

Divide 740 000 ₴ by 168 000 ₴ and you get 4.4 years. Divide 1 240 000 ₴ by 293 000 ₴ and you get 4.23 years. Both figures count the investment alone, without the care through the dead years.

What the recalculation showed

New ground pays back even slightly faster, despite a noticeably more expensive establishment. That is because a new hectare gives the full contribution of 293 000 ₴, while a replanted one adds only the difference against what the old block was giving anyway.

“I was certain that replanting the old was cheaper and more sensible. I counted it — and it came out almost the same. For three evenings I could not come to terms with it.”

A replanted hectare still carries the same 62 000 ₴ of depreciation, even though it cost 740 000 ₴. The trellis and the drip were paid for once, but one day they will have to be replaced too, and that bill has not gone anywhere.

Intuition said the opposite: replanting is cheaper, so it must be better. The figures say that per hryvnia invested the two options are practically equal.

The difference is not in the payback

It is in how much money has to be found today.

New ground is 7 440 000 ₴, which is 9.71 years of the real profit. Replanting is 4 440 000 ₴, which is 5.8 years. The difference is 3 000 000 ₴.

When two options are equally profitable, the choice is made by the money, not by the payback.

And here the nastiest part comes out: the orchard cannot afford either of them. Even the cheaper option is almost six years of the entire real profit.

Where to find the money

It is already there. It simply passes through the till every year and dissolves.

Planting depreciation is 1 488 000 ₴ a year. Over three years that is 4 464 000 ₴.

Replanting six hectares costs 4 440 000 ₴. Three years of depreciation that was never set aside cover it in full, and 24 000 ₴ is left over.

In practice that means three decisions, none of which calls for a loan:

  • show planting depreciation as a separate line in the report
  • set it aside into a separate account every month, not once a year
  • count the profit after it and treat that figure as your own

“So it turns out I had the money for a new orchard for ten years and spent it every year on something else, because nobody ever called it money for a new orchard.”

How this looks on a calendar

Not one of them increases revenue or raises the yield. All they do is make visible a sum that has been passing through the till all this time with no name on it.

Over the first ten years the orchard gives back 14 880 000 ₴ of depreciation. That would be enough both for replanting the old blocks and for new ground, with some left over.

The difference between an orchard that renews itself and an orchard that is seeing out its days is not in yield and not in varieties. It is in whether the depreciation has an account of its own.

What to watch every year

Four figures are enough.

  • how many hectares give a full crop, how many a partial one and how many nothing at all
  • planting depreciation for the year — as a separate line, not inside the fixed costs
  • profit after the depreciation, not before it
  • how much has been set aside for replanting since the start of the year

If the fourth line is zero for the third year running, the orchard is already eating itself, although the report will not say so.

The first line matters more than it seems, too. While the share of young blocks stays within a quarter of the orchard, depreciation that is set aside covers them with room to spare. The problem is not the share, it is that nobody sets that money aside. When the share of blocks with no crop creeps towards half, the orchard works for itself and gives the owner nothing.

Not one of these four lines needs a new accounting system. The owner knows the areas by age of block anyway. The establishment cost is there in the documents. All that is missing is to divide one by the term and put the result into the report as a separate item.

The rest of the indicators in fruit growing matter, but everyone counts them anyway: yield, fruit size, the share of first grade, the losses in storage.

The money does not vanish — you simply do not see it

Fruit growing looks like a business about apples and the weather. In fact it is about how many hectares you are paying for the promise that one day they will bear.

Oksana did not have a problem with her margin. She had an orchard where twenty-six per cent of profit turned out to be nine, because the other seventeen went every year on the wearing out of the plantings.

The profit showed 2 254 000 ₴. The real one was 766 000 ₴. Between those two figures lies 1 488 000 ₴, and that is exactly the sum there was never enough of for a new orchard.

How to see this in your own orchard

All the arithmetic above rests on one row no orchard report has: the annual depreciation of the plantings. While the planting cost is written off in the year of planting, neither the real profit nor the fact that young hectares eat almost everything left is visible. When the same data is collected automatically, profit after depreciation is visible for every block — which is exactly why owners of small and medium businesses use Finmap: to see the financial picture rather than guess at it.

Read also

Table of Contents
Check the Status of Your Business's Financial System
Order Financial Diagnostics
Olena Smolikova
Olena Smolikova
Financial expert at Finmap
  • Head of Finance Department, Beauty Hub Ltd (2020–2024).
  • Head of Management Accounting and Budgeting, Intime LLC (2016–2020).
  • Senior Economist, EdYouGet LLC (2015–2016).
  • Economist with responsibilities of Deputy CFO, Ukrainian Media Holding (2008–2015).

Recommended for Entrepreneurs

Questions that come up right away

How do you count the depreciation of a planting?

Divide the cost of establishing a hectare by the productive life of the planting. Oksana's establishment costs 1 240 000 ₴ and the life is twenty years, which is 62 000 ₴ per hectare every year. Across twenty-four hectares that is 1 488 000 ₴ a year, and this is exactly the line no orchard report has.

In bookkeeping terms it is allowed, and there is nothing to object to in the books. The problem is that after the write-off the owner no longer sees the orchard wearing out, and makes decisions by a profit that takes no account of the wear. In twenty years the block has to be replanted, and no money has been set aside for it.

The visible profit of 2 254 000 ₴ becomes 766 000 ₴ once 1 488 000 ₴ is taken out. The depreciation is 66.0% of the profit, that is two thirds, and 17.4% of revenue — two different bases. The real margin comes out at 8.94% of revenue against the visible 26.3%.

Care of a young hectare is 64 000 ₴ a year and the depreciation 62 000 ₴, together 126 000 ₴ every year for three years. Six young hectares cost 756 000 ₴ a year, while the real profit of the orchard is 766 000 ₴. The difference between those sums is only 10 000 ₴.

Before the first hryvnia, 1 432 000 ₴ in live money has gone into a hectare: establishment of 1 240 000 ₴ plus three years of care at 64 000 ₴. A mature hectare gives a contribution of 293 000 ₴ a year, so 4.89 years of full bearing. Full bearing starts in the sixth year, so about ten years pass between the young tree and the money coming back.

Per hryvnia invested, practically the same. Replanting costs 740 000 ₴ a hectare and gives a gain in contribution of 168 000 ₴, that is 4.4 years. New ground costs 1 240 000 ₴ and gives the full contribution of 293 000 ₴, that is 4.23 years — even slightly faster, despite the dearer establishment.

The sum you have to find today. Six hectares of new ground are 7 440 000 ₴, or 9.71 years of the real profit. Replanting six hectares is 4 440 000 ₴, or 5.8 years. The difference is 3 000 000 ₴, and the orchard cannot afford either option.

Out of the depreciation, if it is set aside separately. Three years at 1 488 000 ₴ give 4 464 000 ₴, and replanting six hectares costs 4 440 000 ₴ — that covers it in full, with 24 000 ₴ left over. Over the first ten years the orchard gives back 14 880 000 ₴.

Any questions left?
We are ready to answer them.
WhatsApp
Telegram
Finmap
Finmap support

Money Doesn't Disappear. You Just Don't See It.

Get a personal financial diagnosis or a Finmap demo — and see your business from a new perspective.

Ask Your Question to a Finmap Expert